Sycamore School won two awards at the IndyStar “2023 Indianapolis Community’s Choice Awards", presented at a November gala at the JW Marriott. Sycamore won the Best-of Award in the Private School category and was also chosen the winner in the After School/Summer Camp category. Sycamore's Melissa Branigan, Tiffany Stahl, Jeremy Kaylor, and Julie SVV attended the gala and accepted the awards.
Sycamore was nominated and voted on by Indianapolis Star readers and the Indy community in August of 2023.. Voting narrowed finalists from an original field of more than 450 down to five. The entire list of winners was published in the Indianapolis Star and in IndyStar online.